- How You Ever Gonna Know prod. by Allen Reynolds
- I Can Be Me With You
- I Don’t Have To Wonder prod. by Allen Reynolds
- I'd Rather Have Nothing
- I'd Rather Have Nothing by Ty England
- I Drove Her to Dallas by Ty England
- If Tomorrow Never Comes prod. by Allen Reynolds
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Michael Ball prod. by Michael Ball & Nigel Wright
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Phil Coulter prod. by Phil Coulter
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Joose prod. by Hamza Lee & Leonardo Pettis
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Ronan Keating prod. by Steve Mac
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Barry Manilow
- If Tomorrow Never Comes by Robforchetta
- I Heard It Through The Grapevine
- I Knew I Loved You by Ty England
- I Know One prod. by Allen Reynolds
- I'll Be The Wind
- In Another's Eyes (Ft. Trisha Yearwood) prod. by Allen Reynolds