- I'll Make a Man Out of You by Donny Osmond prod. by Matthew Wilder
- In a Place of Miracles by Alan Menken (Ft. Andrew Samonsky, Ciara Renee, Erik Liberman & Michael Arden) prod. by Alan Menken, Kurt Deutsch, Michael Kosarin & Stephen Schwartz
- I Need to Know by Original Broadway Cast of Tarzan (Ft. Alex Rutherford) prod. by Frank Filipetti, Paul Bogaev & Phil Collins
- I Never Planned on You/Don't Come a-Knocking by Newsies Original Broadway Cast (Ft. Jeremy Jordan & Kara Lindsay) prod. by Alan Menken, Frank Filipetti, Kurt Deutsch & Michael Kosarin
- Infinity and Beyond (Score) by Randy Newman prod. by Don Davis (Film), Frank Wolf, Jim Flamberg & Randy Newman
- In Summer by Josh Gad prod. by Christophe Beck, Disney, Kristen Anderson-Lopez, Robert Lopez & Tom MacDougall
- Into Notre Dame by Alan Menken (Ft. Ciara Renee, Michael Arden & Patrick Page) prod. by Alan Menken, Kurt Deutsch, Michael Kosarin & Stephen Schwartz
- Io sono Vaiana by Chiara Grispo (Ft. Angela Finocchiaro) prod. by Dave Metzger, Lin-Manuel Miranda & Mark Mancina
- I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here by Alicia Morton (Ft. Audra McDonald) prod. by Frank Wolf & Paul Bogaev
- I Will Go Sailing No More by Randy Newman prod. by Don Davis (Film), Frank Wolf, Jim Flamberg & Randy Newman
- Já Chci Jen To, Co Chci by Tereza Kerndlová prod. by Grace Potter & Mike Daly
- Jeg er Vaiana (Sang til forældrene) by Various Artists prod. by Dave Metzger, Lin-Manuel Miranda & Mark Mancina
- Je suis ton ami by Disney (Ft. Charlélie Couture) prod. by Don Davis (Film), Frank Wolf, Jim Flamberg & Randy Newman
- Je voudrais by Sarah Bismuth prod. by Grace Potter & Mike Daly
- Jumbo Pop Hustle by Michael Giacchino (Ft. Tim Simonec)
- Justice in Paris by Alan Menken prod. by Alan Menken, Kurt Deutsch, Michael Kosarin & Stephen Schwartz
- Kakamora by Mark Mancina prod. by Mark Mancina
- Kingdom Celebration by Alan Menken prod. by Alan Menken & Kevin Kliesch
- Kingdom Dance by Alan Menken prod. by Alan Menken
- Know Who You Are by Auli'i Cravalho, Vai Mahina, Olivia Foa'i, Opetaia Foa'i & Matthew Ineleo prod. by Lin-Manuel Miranda & Mark Mancina