- I Don't Believe in the Sun prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Don't Believe You prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Don't Believe You (7" Version) (Ft. Stephin Merritt)
- I Don’t Know What to Say prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Don't Like Your Tone prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Don’t Really Love You Anymore prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Don't Want to Get Over You prod. by Stephin Merritt
- If I Were A Rich Man prod. by Michael Dore & Stephin Merritt
- If There’s Such a Thing as Love prod. by Stephin Merritt
- If You Don't Cry prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Have the Moon prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I’ll Dream Alone
- I Looked All Over Town prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I'm Sorry I Love You prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I’m Tongue‐Tied prod. by Stephin Merritt
- In an Operetta prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Infatuation (With Your Gyration) prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Infinitely Late at Night prod. by Stephin Merritt
- In My Car prod. by Stephin Merritt
- In My Secret Place prod. by Stephin Merritt