- Interlude prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Irma prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Shatter prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Is This What They Used to Call Love prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Think I Need a New Heart prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Thought You Were My Boyfriend prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Thought You Were My Boyfriend (dub mix)
- I Thought You Were My Boyfriend (single edit)
- It's a Crime prod. by Stephin Merritt
- It’s Only Time prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I've Got a Date with Jesus prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I've Run Away to Join the Fairies prod. by Stephin Merritt
- (I Want to Join A) Biker Gang prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Was Born prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Wish I Had an Evil Twin prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Wish I Had Fangs and a Tail prod. by Stephin Merritt
- I Wish I Were a Prostitute Again prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Jeremy prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Josephine prod. by Stephin Merritt
- Kill a Man a Week prod. by Stephin Merritt