- If You Were Mine by Miranda Lambert & Leon Bridges prod. by Jon Randall
- I Hope You're the End of My Story by Pistol Annies prod. by Chuck Ainlay, Frank Liddell & Glenn Worf
- I Just Really Miss You prod. by Frank Liddell & Mike Wrucke
- I'll Be Lovin' You prod. by Jon Randall & Luke Dick
- I'm Good At Leavin' by Ashley Monroe prod. by Justin Niebank & Vince Gill
- I’m Just an Old Chunk of Coal (But I’m Gonna Be a Diamond Someday)
- I’m Movin’ On
- In His Arms by Jack Ingram, Miranda Lambert & Jon Randall prod. by Jack Ingram & Jon Randall
- In His Arms prod. by Jon Randall & Luke Dick
- Interstate Gospel by Pistol Annies prod. by Eric Masse, Frank Liddell & Glenn Worf
- Interstate Prelude by Pistol Annies prod. by Eric Masse, Frank Liddell & Glenn Worf
- It All Comes Out in the Wash prod. by Jay Joyce
- It Takes One To Know One by Natalie Hemby prod. by Mike Wrucke
- I've Got Wheels prod. by Eric Masse, Frank Liddell & Glenn Worf
- I Wanna Die prod. by Frank Liddell & Mike Wrucke
- I Wish You Were Here by Charles Kelley prod. by Paul Worley
- Jack Daniel's
- Jailhouse Rock
- Jingle Bell Rock by Blake Shelton prod. by Scott Hendricks
- Jive Talkin’ by Barry Gibb (Ft. Jay Buchanan) prod. by Dave Cobb & Stephen Gibb