- I Never Cared for You prod. by Buddy Cannon
- I Never Cared for You (Live) prod. by Buddy Cannon
- In The House of Tom Bombadil by Nickel Creek
- In the Palm of Your Hand by Alison Krauss & The Cox Family
- In Your Eyes prod. by Ken Irwin
- I Should've Known Better by Nickel Creek
- I Still Miss Someone by Dolly Parton prod. by Steve Buckingham
- It All Comes Down to You by Alison Krauss & Union Station prod. by Union Station
- It Doesn't Matter by Alison Krauss & Union Station prod. by Union Station
- It Don’t Bother Me by Robert Plant & Alison Krauss prod. by T Bone Burnett
- It Don't Matter Now
- It's Goodbye and So Long to You prod. by Buddy Cannon
- It's Not Over (If I'm Not over You) by Mark Chesnutt (Ft. Vince Gill) prod. by Mark Wright
- It's Over prod. by Bil Vorndick & Jerry Douglas
- It Won't Rain Always by Gaither & Jamey Johnson
- It Won't Work This Time by Alison Krauss & Union Station prod. by Alison Krauss & Union Station
- It Wouldn't Have Made Any Difference
- I've Got That Old Feeling prod. by Bil Vorndick & Jerry Douglas
- I Will by Tony Furtado prod. by Michael Marshall
- Jacob's Dream