- I Found A Love, Part II by Wilson Pickett
- I Found The One by Wilson Pickett
- If You Gotta Make a Fool of Somebody by Aretha Franklin prod. by Tom Dowd
- I Had A Dream by Ray Charles prod. by Ahmet Ertegün
- I Know by The Drifters prod. by Ahmet Ertegün
- I Know It’s You by Donny Hathaway prod. by Arif Mardin
- Iko Iko by Dr. John prod. by Harold Battiste
- I'll Never Be Free by Aretha Franklin prod. by Tom Dowd
- I'll Never Be Free by LaVern Baker
- I'll Remember April by Bobby Darin prod. by Ahmet Ertegün & Nesuhi Ertegün
- I'll Take You Where the Music's Playing by The Drifters prod. by Bert Berns
- I Love Every Little Thing About You by Aretha Franklin prod. by Aretha Franklin, Arif Mardin & Tom Dowd
- I Love You More Than You'll Ever Know by Donny Hathaway prod. by Arif Mardin
- I Love You More Than You'll Ever Know (Live at The Bitter End, New York City, 1971) by Donny Hathaway prod. by Arif Mardin
- I'm Drifting by Wilson Pickett prod. by Jim Stewart
- I'm Gonna Cry by Wilson Pickett prod. by Jim Stewart
- I'm Hanging Up My Heart for You by Solomon Burke prod. by Bert Berns
- I'm in a Crying Mood by LaVern Baker
- I'm In Love by Aretha Franklin prod. by Aretha Franklin & Arif Mardin