- Hit the Switch (Companion Version) by Bright Eyes
- Hole in One by Desaparecidos prod. by David Dondero
- Hot Car in the Sun by Bright Eyes prod. by Bright Eyes
- Hot Knives by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis
- Hubcap
- Hundreds of Ways prod. by Jonathan Wilson
- I Believe in Symmetry by Bright Eyes prod. by Bright Eyes
- I Disappear by The Faint
- I Don’t Wanna Die (In the Hospital) by Conor Oberst and The Mystic Valley Band
- I Don't Want To Die In The Hospital
- If Only by Maria Taylor prod. by Nik Freitas
- If the Brakeman Turns My Way by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis
- If Winter Ends by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis
- I Got the Reason #1 by Conor Oberst and The Mystic Valley Band
- I Got the Reason (No. 2) by Conor Oberst and The Mystic Valley Band
- I Know the End by Phoebe Bridgers prod. by Ethan Gruska, Phoebe Bridgers, Tony Berg & The Trilemma
- I Know the End by Chris Lanzon
- I Know You by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis
- I'll Be Your Friend by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis
- I Must Belong Somewhere by Bright Eyes prod. by Mike Mogis