- I Got Lost prod. by J Mascis
- I Know It Oh So Well prod. by J Mascis
- I Know Yer Insane
- I Know You're Insane prod. by J Mascis
- I Live for That Look prod. by J Mascis
- Imagination Blind prod. by J Mascis
- I Met the Stones prod. by J Mascis & Kurt Vile
- I'm Insane prod. by J Mascis
- In a Jar prod. by Wharton Tiers
- In a Jar (Live)
- I Ran Away prod. by J Mascis & Kurt Vile
- I Ran Away (Live from The Sinclair) (Unreleased)
- I Told Everyone prod. by J Mascis
- It's Me prod. by J Mascis
- I Walk For Miles prod. by J Mascis
- I Want You To Know prod. by J Mascis
- Just Like Heaven prod. by Wharton Tiers
- Just Like Heaven (Live from The Sinclair) (Unreleased)
- Keeblin' prod. by J Mascis