- I Dig Music by Rheostatics
- I Don't Like by Barenaked Ladies
- I Fab Thee by Rheostatics prod. by Rheostatics
- If I Had $1,000,000 by Barenaked Ladies
- I Have Learned by Barenaked Ladies
- I Know by Barenaked Ladies prod. by Barenaked Ladies
- I Live with It Every Day by Barenaked Ladies prod. by Barenaked Ladies
- I'll Never Tear You Apart by Martin Tielli
- I Love You by Barenaked Ladies
- In It Now by Rheostatics
- Insomnia by Kevin Hearn
- In the Country by Kevin Hearn and Thin Buckle prod. by Jeremy Darby, Jim Scott & Kevin Hearn
- In the Drink by Barenaked Ladies prod. by Barenaked Ladies
- In the Minnow Trap by Kevin Hearn and Thin Buckle prod. by Jeremy Darby & Kevin Hearn
- In the Shade by Kevin Hearn and Thin Buckle prod. by Kevin Hearn
- In This Town by Rheostatics
- Introducing Happiness by Rheostatics
- Invisible Stairs by Rheostatics prod. by Rheostatics
- I Saw It by Barenaked Ladies
- It by Rheostatics