- I Can't Let You Go prod. by Arif Mardin
- I Can't See Nobody prod. by Ossie Byrne & Robert Stigwood
- I Close My Eyes prod. by Ossie Byrne & Robert Stigwood
- I Could Not Love You More prod. by Barry Gibb, David Foster, Maurice Gibb & Robin Gibb
- Idea prod. by Robert Stigwood
- I Don’t Know Why I Bother with Myself prod. by Nat Kipner
- I Don't Think It's Funny prod. by Bill Shepherd
- I Don’t Wanna Be the One prod. by Barry Gibb, Maurice Gibb & Robin Gibb
- If I Can't Have You prod. by Albhy Galuten & Karl Richardson
- If I Were The Sky
- If Only I Had My Mind on Something Else prod. by Robert Stigwood
- I Have Decided to Join the Air Force prod. by Robert Stigwood
- I Held a Party prod. by Barry Gibb, Maurice Gibb, Robert Stigwood & Robin Gibb
- I Laugh in Your Face prod. by Robert Stigwood
- I Lay Down and Die prod. by Robert Stigwood
- I'll Kiss Your Memory
- I'll Know What to Do prod. by Nat Kipner
- I Love You Because prod. by Nat Kipner
- I Love You Too Much prod. by Albhy Galuten, Barry Gibb, Karl Richardson, Maurice Gibb & Robin Gibb
- Immortality by Céline Dion prod. by Walter Afanasieff