- Honey Don’tcha Leave Me Tonight prod. by Maurice Starr
- House Party (Ft. Big Freedia, Boyz II Men, Jordin Sparks & Naughty By Nature) prod. by Donnie Wahlberg & Lars Halvor Jensen
- I Can't Believe It's Over prod. by Narada Michael Walden
- If You Go Away prod. by Walter Afanasieff
- I’ll Be Loving You (Forever) prod. by Maurice Starr
- I'll Be Loving You (Forever) (More 7" Remix Version) prod. by Maurice Starr
- I'll Be Missing You Come Christmas (A Letter to Santa) prod. by Maurice Starr
- I'll Be Missin You Come Christmas (A Letter to Santa)
- I'll Be Waitin' prod. by Brad Young, Danny Wood & Dow Brain
- I'll Still Be Loving You prod. by Michael Mani, Monty Seward & Narada Michael Walden
- I Need You prod. by Maurice Starr
- In the Night prod. by Deekay, Donnie Wahlberg & Pink Laces
- Intro: Face the Music prod. by Donnie Wahlberg
- I Remember When prod. by Maurice Starr
- I Still Believe in Santa Claus prod. by Maurice Starr
- I Wanna Be Loved by You prod. by Maurice Starr
- Jealous (Blue) prod. by Deekay
- Keepin' My Fingers Crossed prod. by Richard Wolf
- Keep on Smilin’ prod. by Narada Michael Walden
- Kids prod. by David Stewart & Luke Batt