- I Don't Want Your Loving prod. by Jim Scott
- (If You're Wondering If I Want You to) I Want You To prod. by Butch Walker
- II. Anonymous prod. by Ric Ocasek
- I Just Threw Out the Love of My Dreams
- I Love the USA prod. by Jake Sinclair
- I'm a Robot prod. by Chad Bamford
- I'm Just Being Honest prod. by David Andrew Sitek
- I'm Your Daddy prod. by Dr. Luke
- I Need Some of That prod. by Suzy Shinn
- In the Garage prod. by Ric Ocasek
- In the Mall prod. by Jacknife Lee
- Island in the Sun prod. by Ric Ocasek
- It’s Always Sunny in Bikini Bottom prod. by Suzy Shinn
- It's Been So Long
- I've Had It Up to Here prod. by Ric Ocasek
- I've Thrown It All Away prod. by Suzy Shinn
- I Want a Dog prod. by James Flannigan, Rivers Cuomo & Suzy Shinn
- Jacked Up prod. by Jake Sinclair
- Jacked Up (Remix) (Ft. FITZ & Nadezhda Tolokonnikova) prod. by Jake Sinclair