- I Love You Like a Table by Christopher Fitzgerald (Ft. Kimiko Glenn) prod. by Jill Dell'abate, Nadia DiGiallonardo & Neal Avron
- Islands prod. by John O'Mahony & Kurt Uenala
- It Only Takes a Taste by Drew Gehling (Ft. Jessie Mueller) prod. by Jill Dell'abate, Nadia DiGiallonardo & Neal Avron
- I Wanna Be Like Me prod. by John O'Mahony
- James In The Bathroom (2019 Tony Awards) by James Corden (Ft. Josh Groban & Neil Patrick Harris)
- King of Anything prod. by Neal Avron
- King of the Lost Boys prod. by Tyler Chester
- Let the Rain prod. by Neal Avron
- Lie to Me prod. by Ben Folds
- Little Black Dress prod. by John O'Mahony
- Look for the Light by Only Murders in the Building – Cast (Ft. Ashley Park & Meryl Streep) prod. by Benj Pasek, Ian Eisendrath & Justin Paul
- Love on the Rocks prod. by Gabriel Mann
- Love Song prod. by Eric Rosse
- Lulu's Pie Song prod. by Neal Avron
- Machine Gun prod. by Neal Avron
- Manhattan prod. by John O'Mahony
- Many the Miles prod. by Eric Rosse
- Maybe They're Magic by Sara Bareilles & Brian d'Arcy James prod. by Sean Patrick Flahaven
- Miss Simone prod. by T Bone Burnett
- Morningside prod. by Eric Rosse